Our prayers are with the family. Out of the hundreds, or perhaps even thousands of suicide investigations McDonald said hes worked on, he admitted the Greenberg case is one of the most unusualhes ever seen in his career. The AGs office pointed to new computer forensic evidencenot referenced in the medical examiners 2011 findings. To use this feature, use a newer browser. Miss greenberg was a very large inspiration to my son Montez. Arie Luyendyk Jr. Parents, Siblings And Family. No animated GIFs, photos with additional graphics (borders, embellishments. Ellen Rae Greenberg had everything going for her when she was found dead in the apartment she shares with her fianc. Please contact Find a Grave at [emailprotected] if you need help resetting your password. Are you sure that you want to delete this memorial? Your family is in our prayers. She was very dedicated to teaching and cared about everyone. Ellen A. Greenberg, age 90 of Nowthen, passed into the arms of her Lord and Savior on March 20, 2022. Verify and try again. She was anxious but she was still happy, her father, Joshua Greenberg, added. [14], Following The Philadelphia Inquirer investigation, the case became a sensation in the true crime community. Remove advertising from a memorial by sponsoring it for just $5. Greenberg's parents, however, remain convinced that . Historical Person Search Search Search Results Results Ellen Rae Greenberg (1983 - 2011) Try FREE for 14 days Try FREE for 14 days. This new information is very powerful, Podraza tells CBS Phillyin an interview. For memorials with more than one photo, additional photos will appear here or on the photos tab. We were all blessed to have known her. They provided a search history from Ellens computer, which showed she had used an internet search browser to look up suicide. Pa. Use Next and Previous buttons to navigate, or jump to a slide with the slide dots. Please accept our deepest sympathy and know that you are in our thoughts and prayers. She chickened out [of getting her ears pierced] she didnt like pain, her own pain, her father Joshua Greenberg told Oxygen.com. Sandee, Josh, Linda and the rest of the family, I am a 6th grader at juniata park academy and when i heard the news i was really sad even though i didnt know her. Ellen Rae Greenberg was a young teacher who taught first grade at Juniata Park Academy in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. Brennans sleuthing led him to forensic pathologist Wayne Ross, whom he hired to examine a fragment of Ellens spinal cord, which the medical examiners office was still in possession of. Liked it? This memorial has been copied to your clipboard. Ellen was a fantastic teacher and a great person. He found Greenberg on the kitchen floor of their two-bedroom apartment with a 10-inch serrated steak knife jammed several inches into her chest. These, he said, were representative of a knife attack. Try again later. I worked with Ellen at Colonial Middle School and got to know her very well. She was born on June 23, 1983 in New York, NY to Joshua & Sandra. She bounced with an energy and a vitality that was unique to Ellen. The 27-year-old reportedly filled her car up with gas and returned to the Philadelphia apartment she shared with her fianc, Sam Goldberg. If youre in charge of handling the affairs for a recently deceased loved one, this guide offers a helpful checklist. I am at a loss for words. [10] However, the next day, the Philadelphia Police Department backtracked and stated that, "the death of Ellen Greenberg has not been ruled a homicideHomicide investigators are considering the manner of death as suspicious at this time. To the Greeberg Family, our deepest sympathy goes out to your family. Greenbergs parents also told Oxygen.comthe fact that Ellen filled up her vehicle with gas before returning to her apartment on Jan. 26, 2011, is something they found odd, if their daughter was planning to kill herself. Please ensure you have given Find a Grave permission to access your location in your browser settings. "[4] Similarly, forensic scientist Henry Lee, who testified for the defense in the O. J. Simpson murder trial reviewed the case files and concluded, "[t]he number and types of wounds and bloodstain patterns observed are consistent with a homicide scene. Before her death, Ellen had expressed a desire to temporarily move back home to Harrisburg, P.A. There are no volunteers for this cemetery. I am keeping your family in prayerI guess you are walking with the angels now..peace. You can be proud of her and how she touched so many children and colleagues. Comedy. I am very saddened to hear the loss of my peer, Ellen. Read More Cory Hall Death And Obituary: Raymond Nottingham And Jadarrious Markell Sears Arrested And Charged For ShootingContinue, The demise Kenyan musician became a trending topic after Gospel World announced Ilagosa Wa Ilagosa Death via Facebook. This browser does not support getting your location. In November 2022, an appeals court heard arguments. Sim Wong Hoo Death Cause And Obituary: How Did Founder Of Creative Technology Die? We have set your language to Morbid. The best poems for funerals, memorial services., and cards. To learn more about the mysterious case, tune in to Oxygens Accident, Suicide or Murder, streaming now. Get browser notifications for breaking news, live events, and exclusive reporting. 0 cemeteries found in Harrisburg, Dauphin County, Pennsylvania, USA. In 2017, Ross concluded Ellens cranial cavity had been punctured, which would have likely rendered her unconsciousand prevented her from stabbing herself so many times. Please complete the captcha to let us know you are a real person. They're not a map to follow, but simply a description of what people commonly feel. And Ellens family also corroborated this, telling police Goldberg was a fine, young man.". The re-reversal upended the Greenbergs' lives. IM SORRY TO HEAR ABOUT THIS TRAGEDY, ELLEN WAS A VERY HIGH SPIRITED PERSON, VERY CONFIDENT WITHIN HERSELF, SHE WILL BE MISSED VERY MUCH. She chickened out [of getting her ears pierced]she didn't like pain, her own pain, said Joshua. She had been stabbed more than 20 times with wounds to the back of her skull, neck and chest. Advertisement. Sincerest sympathy for the loss of your child and an amazing person. My prayers will continue to be with your family during this time of mourning and the days and months ahead. Create your free profile and get access to exclusive content. May you know that you are in the thoughts and prayers of so many who care. Share this memorial using social media sites or email. You are nearing the transfer limit for memorials managed by Find a Grave. Photo: Because of her nurturing characteristics, Ellen went into teaching . memorial page for Ellen Rae Greenberg (23 Jun 1983-26 Jan 2011), Find a Grave Memorial ID 64780765 . Im going to be six feet under [before this over], added Joshua. Legal battle over Ellen Greenberg's death continues. [9] However, despite there being no suicide note, the crime scene was treated as a suicide. Are you sure that you want to remove this flower? Take a second to support Gavin Fish on Patreon! [3] Incident [ edit] USA. To the Greenberg Family, I worked with Ellen at JPA. Resend Activation Email. Ellen is the daughter of Joshua Greenberg and Sandra Greenberg, who both work in the dental field. Even though we have been distant in the past years. This is critical, attorney Joe Podraza tells "48 Hours." The Greenbergs are now suing Philadelphia, trying to change Ellen's manner of death from suicide to homicide or undetermined. [1] [2] Ellen, an only child, was born in New York City, New York to Joshua (Josh) and Sandra (Sandee) Greenberg. No matter how much they scratch around, its still going to stink.. My heart goes out to you all, and my prayers and thoughts are with you. Are you sure that you want to report this flower to administrators as offensive or abusive? David Kessler's top 4 tips for dealing with holiday grief. This is a carousel with slides. In the years since her death, several prestigious forensic pathologists, including Dr. Cyril Wecht, have disagreed with Osbournes suicide finding. Memorials. Expand the Memories and Condolences form. Richard Goldberg in purple tie third from left. Unless you are experienced as an estate executor, you probably should hire an attorney. Her search history reportedly included the terms suicide methods," "quick suicide," and "painless suicide., It remainsunclear why this forensics report wasnt included in the medical examiners 2011 investigation, which stated there wasnt anything indicative of suicide on the computers or in the rest of the apartment., Brennan, the former Pennsylvania detective, called the attorney generals findings totally ridiculous., Theres not enough litter in the box, he said. The reason? We didnt believe it was a suicide.. In homicides, McDonald explained, shallow stab wounds are uncommon. This account has been disabled. To add a flower, click the Leave a Flower button. That same point was also raised by Henry Lee, a forensic scientist who testified for the defense at the O.J. Medical Examiners Office investigator Stephen Olszewski stays on-scene to ensure that the knife in Ellens chest isnt removed. Ellen Greenberg was murdered by way of 20 stab wounds, with 10 alone to the back of Ellen's neck. Typically if a person is stabbing you, theyre not going to stab you several times superficially and then start to stab you deeper. Ms. Ware contacts the police to ask permission to let him enter. Sim Wong Hoo, the CEO of Creative Technology, has recently passed away. Brice and Kristi Arndt. / CBS Philadelphia. Jim Villarreal/Mr V. I knew Ellen from the STHS softball team and remember looking up to her, one of my older and wiser teammates. They said there were no signs of intrusion, and the victim had no defensive wounds. Sam Goldberg can be seen in the "Camera 2, 3pm to 5pm" video entering the gym at about 4:54:37. For the past eight years, the first grade teachers parents have been waging a painstaking, and so far fruitless, crusade to uncover what exactly happened to their only child. A number of podcasts have also detailed Greenberg's death, including the Criminology Podcast (featuring Cyril H. Wecht), Sinisterhood, Catch My Killer, Generation Why, Strange and Unexplained, Stephanie Harlowe's YouTube channel,[22] Rachel Shannon's YouTube channel, Gavin Fish's YouTube Channel,[23] Killer Podcast, GRWM, Late Night Crimecsat, Sideline Sleuths, Kendall Rae's YouTube channel,[24] Bouquet of Madness, Women & Crime, Crime Junkie and Morbid: A True Crime Podcast. Ellen Rae Greenberg (June 23, 1983 - January 26, 2011) was a 27-year-old first grade teacher at Juniata Park Academy in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. Suicidal stab wounds can rarely be multiple, Wecht wrote in the 2012 report. Please know all our thoughts are with you. I am now in high school and hopefully making her proud . It has been nearly a decade since the death of Ellen Greenberg and forensic experts are still at odds about how the 27-year-old teacher died. 2020 CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved. Oops, some error occurred while uploading your photo(s). Philadelphia authorities say she killed herself but they refuse to believe that. Her parents insisted that their daughter had always been squeamish about blood and would have never willingly inflicted so many knife wounds. At approximately 6:40 p.m. on January 26, 2011, Ellen was pronounced dead as a result of twenty stab wounds, including ten to the back of her head and neck. In order to protect her employer, Ms. Ware makes a video recording of the state of the apartment prior to having the apartment cleaned. But her parents, Josh and Sandra Greenberg, say they never believed it and began a nine-year search to find out how their daughter died. Eventually, Goldberg, a television producer who'd been with Greenberg for three years, forced his way into the suite with a building attendant. Please try again later. Sign the Justice for Ellen petition. Earlier this month, the attorney generals spokesman released their latest findings to The Inquirer. released a front-page investigative report on March 15, 2019, evaluating the suspicious circumstances around the death of Ellen Greenberg. My thoughts and prayers are extended to her family and friends. The Kenya-native Singer was also a pastor, Read More Ilagosa Wa Ilagosa Death Cause And Obituary: How Did Musical Artist Die?Continue, Her death case became a sensation in the true crime community and was featured in, The mystery and suspicion surrounding her death have also led to episodes in, Did Karen Carpenter Have Kids With Her Husband Thomas James Burris? Send simple, comforting meals with Home Chef. First published on November 15, 2022 / 7:21 PM. Police are quick to say she died by suicide - despite the 20 stab wounds she sustained. or don't show this againI am good at figuring things out. I will forever how much help she gave me and my daughter. They also hired an attorney, Joseph Podraza, to change the cause of death to homicide. [4], Following the autopsy, the Philadelphia Medical Examiner's Office initially ruled the case as a homicide. Pavel Antov Death: Russian Philanthropist Found Death In Hotel in Odisha; Case Update, Is Don Postles Hospitalized? Death of Ellen Greenberg. Your account has been locked for 30 minutes due to too many failed sign in attempts. By Dorian Geiger Ellen Rae Greenberg Photo: Justice for Ellen/Facebook She was taken from you far too soon. When we found out certain facts along the wayshe had wounds on her back. Her parents told CBS News they were disgusted and disappointed by the finding and . Crime News is your destination for true crime stories from around the world, breaking crime news, and information about Oxygen's original true crime shows and documentaries. The suit aimed to change the nature of death from suicide to homicide or undetermined, citing the availably of new information. The case was reversed and officially deemed a suicide in February 2011, with no explanation given to the Greenbergs. Jlkb, hi my name is latonya moore and ellen Greenberg was my teacher wene I was in 3rd grade and now im in 7th she was my reading teacher and I loved he she was the best teacher iv ever had and that day befor we left for the wenter brake I did see her and gave her a hug and toold her I would see her wene we get back to school but it turns out that that day I was wching tv I heard that she passed away and I did not get to say goodbye I just want to say I love you and r.i.p an I will keep my head up looking for you, remeber me your best student litzy .i hope you get my message love litzy, i did not get to meet u at all but from what i hear with my daughter isabelita robles u was a great teacher may u rest in peace. Source: Thomas P Brennan Equivocal Death Analysis, Source: Medical Examiners Office Autopsy Report, Draft (Homicide). The file of Ellen Greenberg is being closed by the office of Pennsylvania Attorney General Josh Shapiro, according to a letter sent to the attorney of Greenberg's parents. Yet, the Greenbergs are adamant this isnt the end. Investigators also didnt find any note or suggestion inside the apartment that Ellen had been considering suicide. It could take a few months before a decision is made. cemeteries found within miles of your location will be saved to your photo volunteer list. Sam is present. "You can tell that it's very improbable that Ellen could inflict the wounds from behind. I am a former student of ms.greenberg . They dont get the opportunity to defend themselves.. January 26th, 2021 is the 10th anniversary of Ellen Rae Greenberg's unfortunate death. He started Creative Technology in, Read More Sim Wong Hoo Death Cause And Obituary: How Did Founder Of Creative Technology Die?Continue, Two days before Pavel Antovs death, his Party mateVladimir Budanov mysteriously passed away in a hotel in Rayagada, Odisha. In another shooting, two teenagers were shot, and one died later at the hospital while being treated. It doesnt fit.. "By definition, meaning it was inflicted when Ellen was dead, makes it clear that she could not have self-inflicted all 20 or any of the 20, frankly, of those wounds," Podraza said. You are only allowed to leave one flower per day for any given memorial. with her parents, they said. Flowers added to the memorial appear on the bottom of the memorial or here on the Flowers tab. "She did not kill herself," Sandee Greenberg, Ellen's mother, said. We encourage you to research and examine . Box 852 Hershey, PA 17033-0852. In a copy of the civil complaint obtained by "48 Hours," attorneys note some stark disagreements between what investigators have said and what other experts are saying. She was a beautiful person and will remain in my memory as such. Ellen's psychiatrist told police the schoolteacher had expressed "uneasiness" in taking medication, but that "there was never any indication of abusive behavior.". Both drugs, particularly clonazepam, a benzodiazepine, are known to induce suicidal ideation in some patients. She could have done it physically, of course. Over the course of more than 20 minutes, Goldberg sent a series of increasingly frantic tests to his fiance'sphone. Grief researchers say holding that missing funeral service, even a year or more later, can still help us heal. Ellen Greenberg's parents Sandee and Josh have been fighting to change Ellen's death certificate from suicide to homicide or undetermined since 2011 and have recently sued former employees in the Philadelphia Medical Examiner's Office. "However, I have no recollection of such a case.". But he found himself on the fence between suicide and homicide. Memorials. Praying for your family & hoping the wonderful memories of Ellen bring you some comfort <3. The process, called photogrammetry, allowed the legal team to recreate Ellen's anatomical and physiological attributes. My mom has often spoken so highly of Ellen and I am so sorry to hear of your loss. memorial page for Ellen Rae Greenberg (23 Jun 1983-26 Jan 2011), . The Greenbergs obtained Ellens autopsy report and hired a plethora of medical experts, lawyers, and law enforcement officials to look at her case. Words can not express the loss of Ellen, a beauiful and amazing daughter, friend and person. GOD be with you all. He said its possible Ellen was taken by complete surprise when she was stabbed. Until [Ellen] is cleared of being suicidal, its not over.. Her fianc cooperated with authorities, was interviewed, and released. Her death case became a sensation in the true crime community and was featured inThe PhiladelphiaInquirer,Dr. Oz Show,People Magazine,48 Hours, etc. He accompanies Ellen to the morgue. You can always change this later in your Account settings. More than a decade after her death, the city of Philadelphia stands firm in its belief that 27-year-old Ellen Rae Greenberg died by suicide. Though only meeting Miss greenberg once, she was a delight! [Its] very frustrating, very emotionally frustrating, emotionally hurtful, said Ellens father, now 69. . Theres a big holetheres a tremendous hole in our lives, her fatherJoshua said. "I think this is a vicious homicide," Josh said. They are hopeful the investigation by the Chester County DA will be thorough and objective. I will always remember her. Her fianc . In lieu of flowers, memorial contributions in Ellen's honor may be made to the Penn State 4 Diamonds Fund, Milton S. Hershey Medical Center, Office of University Development, A120, 600 Centerview Drive, P.O. I am so very saddened by the loss of Ellen. The Greenbergs' attorney, Joe Podraza, argued to a panel of three judges that images forensically proved Ellen could not have stabbed herself almost 20 times. Ten of those punctures were found on her neck. Ellen was born on June 23rd of 1983. in New York City. Dear Sandee, Josh and all the family and friends of Ellen. May you find comfort in the many wonderful memories you have. A native of New York City, she was the only child to her parents, Joshua and Sandra Greenberg. Wecht said he was delighted the case would be re-examined by the Chester County District Attorneys Office. She was born on June 23, 1983 in New York, NY to Joshua & Sandra (Rubin) Greenberg. There is a problem with your email/password. Part of that new evidence is the deposition of a medical expert who reexamined a part of Greenberg's spinal tissue, which found some interesting results. Greenberg had her life cut short at just 27 years old after she was found dead. Resend Activation Email, Please check the I'm not a robot checkbox, If you want to be a Photo Volunteer you must enter a ZIP Code or select your location on the map. There were traces of zolpidem, a sedative and sleep aide, and clonazepam, an anti-anxiety medication,in Ellen's system when she died, according to a toxicology report. She was so beautiful on the outside and the inside as well. All photos appear on this tab and here you can update the sort order of photos on memorials you manage. "That's just a basic medical proposition that no one disputes. Months after his initial ruling, Dr. Osbourne reversed the cause of death to say suicide. Esteemed forensic pathologist Cyril Wecht, who disputed the singlebullet theory of John F. Kennedys assassination, and Henry Lee, the forensic scientist who testified on behalf of O.J. Ellen A. Greenberg age 90 of Nowthen, passed into the arms of her Lord and Savior on March 20, 2022. My thoughts and prayers are with you in your time of need. But shortly before her death, family and friends observed a distinct change in the normally bubbly 27-year-old. Arrangements are being handled by the Hetrick-Bitner Funeral Home. Ilagosa Wa Ilagosa Death Cause And Obituary: How Did Musical Artist Die. Theres no way my daughter would harm herself or anyone else, her motherSandee said. If you have questions, please contact [emailprotected]. I'm disappointed that I didn't stay in touch over the past couple years. My deepest sympathies go out to you. Ellen A. Greenberg, age 90 of Nowthen, passed into the arms of her Lord and Savior on March 20, 2022.Survived by her children, Rollie (Kate) Greenberg, Shirley Greenberg and Jim (Olya) Greenberg; gran Also Read:Did Karen Carpenter Have Kids With Her Husband Thomas James Burris? "What's significant here is that there's no hemorrhage," Lyndsey Emery, a neuropathologist, said in her deposition. Lastmonth, Philadelphia Inquirer reporter Stephanie Farr published an extensively researched article, which has revived local and national interest in the Greenberg case, and raised deep-rooted questions over the teachers death. Ellen Greenberg death is still a big mystery and something that has been highly disputed. "The rest of the apartment was pretty unremarkable.". There was an error deleting this problem. May your memories bring you comfort. Surviving in addition to her parents are her maternal grandmother Linda (Rubin) Schwab of Harrisburg and her fianc Samuel Hankin Goldberg of Gladwyne, PA. Funeral services will be held at 1 pm on Friday, January 28, 2011 in the Beth El Temple Sanctuary, 2637 North Front Street, Harrisburg, PA, with Rabbi Eric Cytryn officiating. My thoughts and prayers are with you in your time of grief. What Happened To Him- Illness And Health UpdateContinue, Views are curious about Emmett Till Killer after announcing a new play, Trial in the Delta: The Murder of Emmett Till, revolving around his murder mystery. This is not a clear cut case of suicide, echoed Walter Cohen, former Pennsylvania state attorney general, and one of the Greenbergs' lawyers, told Oxygen.com. The law enforcement veteran referred to this as a blitz attack, which he said wouldve left Ellen totally defenseless and could explain the absence of a struggle. To plant trees in memory, please visit the. Shortly after, an autopsy reversed Greenbergs cause of death tohomicide. She will be missed by so many. And to this day, the Greenbergs dont believe their daughter killed herself. Ellen Greenberg "Justice for Ellen 2019" Facebook page The search for answers began nine years ago, on January 26, 2011, when Ellen Greenberg was found dead on the kitchen floor. All photos uploaded successfully, click on the Done button to see the photos in the gallery. Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. She was always looking out for her students & I visit the memorial garden we have at jpa all the time . Region. The Olympic champion got hospitalized on January 10, 2023. Please take some time, even if it's just a few minutes every couple of days, and watch these videos. Even something as small as teaching me and Matthew how to blow bubble gum sticks with me as one of my fondest memories. March 11, 2020 / 2:37 PM Justice for Ellen GoFundMe Page Ellen's psychiatrist, Dr. Ellen Berman, prescribed them to Ellen in the weeks leading up to her death. He also noted the deeper stab wounds, the number of punctures, and a gash that was also found on Ellens forehead complicated the case. Tim Cooney told the Inquirer. Recreations of Ellen Greenberg's wounds, made with information from the medical examiner's report. Shourron(Maintenance Dept), My name is Deborah Merritt. Pennsylvania. With our greatest of sympathies, Pam Miller and Thomas Hom. I met Ellen in a class at Penn State. To view a photo in more detail or edit captions for photos you added, click the photo to open the photo viewer. Ellen Rae Greenberg, 27, of Philadelphia and formerly of Harrisburg, passed away in her home on Wednesday, January 26, 2011. But investigators told reporters the next day they were "leaning" towards suicide, according to the Inquirer. [Theyre] confronted unexpectedly. Sign up forOxygen Insiderfor all the best true crime content. For eight years,Joshua and Sandee Greenberghave tirelessly investigated the death oftheir 27-year-old daughter, Ellen, who was found stabbed to death in her apartment. Husband of woman murdered with an ax convicted 40 years after her death, The Brighton ax murder: A timeline of the 40-year-old cold case, How a tragic boating crash is connected to the family of Alex Murdaugh, Chilling details revealed in JJ Vallow and Tylee Ryan deaths, Moms chatting at a water park help crack a cold case murder, family attorney Joe Podraza tells CBS Philly. Family of teacher who died from 20 stab wounds sues Philadelphia medical examiner to have suicide ruling changed, "Medical Examiner's Office Investigation Report - Ellen Greenberg Case Docs", "Deposition of Marlon Osbourne, MD - Ellen Greenberg Case Docs", Authorities say the cause of a Philadelphia teacher's death was suicide, but her parents say it was murder, Police consider Manayunk death 'suspicious': not homicide, Family hopes new lawsuit ends search for answers in daughter's mysterious death, Parents Score Legal Victory in 9 Year Search for Answers, Suicide or Homicide: Mystery over Ellen Greenberg's Death Baffles Experts, "Teacher Had 20 Stab Wounds, Yet 2011 Death Was Ruled Suicide Now DA Is Reopening Investigation". A new technology called photogrammetry, which was previously unavailable, created a 3D anatomical recreation of Greenbergs wounds, showing that all 20 wounds could not have been self-inflicted. USA. Ellen was prescribed Ambien and Klonopin to help her sleep. At approximately 6:40 p.m. on January 26, 2011, Ellen was pronounced dead as a result of twenty stab wounds, including ten to the back of her head and neck. As the cases peculiarities trickled in, the Greenbergs' suspicions grew. [4] Pittsburgh forensic pathologist Cyril H. Wecht, who famously challenged the single-bullet theory of the John F. Kennedy assassination, reviewed the case and determined it was "strongly suspicious of homicide" also stated, "I don't know how they wrote this off as a suicide. Most people who commit suicide dont stab themselves through the clothes, they usually pull the clothes up and usually expose whatever area they want to target, so that was a little unusual for a suicide.. Oxygen Insider is your all-access pass to never-before-seen content, free digital evidence kits, and much more. Check out never-before-seen content, free digital evidence kits, and much more! The only other entrance to their apartment was through their balcony, but it was on the sixth floor. It was a typical conversation. She had twenty stab wounds, including ten to her back and neck. Simpsons defense, both authored independent reports questioning the manner of Ellens death.
